ENGROSSED

COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE

FOR

COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE

FOR

Senate Bill No. 429

(By Senators Bowman, Wooton, White, Snyder,

Hunter, Deem, Kessler, Schoonover and Ball)

____________

[Originating in the Committee on Finance;

reported March 6, 1998.]

____________

A BILL to amend and reenact section five, article twenty-nine, chapter eighteen of the code of West Virginia, one thousand nine hundred thirty-one, as amended; to amend and reenact sections three, four, five, six, seven and ten, article six- a, chapter twenty-nine of said code; and to further amend said article by adding thereto a new section, designated section twelve, all relating to the education and public employees grievance process; providing for expedited grievance processes; expanding the jurisdiction of the board; changing the default provisions; giving board procedural jurisdiction at levels two and three; allowing mediation at the request of any party; allowing appeals to be filed in the circuit court of Kanawha County; and increasing the cap on attorney's fees for prevailing grievants.

Be it enacted by the Legislature of West Virginia:
That section five, article twenty-nine, chapter eighteen of the code of West Virginia, one thousand nine hundred thirty-one, as amended, be amended and reenacted; that sections three, four, five, six, seven and ten, article six-a, chapter twenty-nine of said code be amended and reenacted; and that said article be further amended by adding thereto a new section, designated section twelve, all to read as follows:
CHAPTER 18. EDUCATION.
ARTICLE 29. GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE.
§18-29-5. Education and state employees grievance board; hearing examiners.

(a) There is hereby created and shall be an The education and state employees grievance board which shall consist of three members who shall be are citizens of the state appointed by the governor by and with the advice and consent of the Senate for overlapping terms of three years. except that the original appointments shall be for a period of one, two and three years, respectively, commencing on the first day of July, one thousand nine hundred eighty-five No two members shall may be from the same congressional district, and no more than two of the appointed members shall may be from the same political party. No person shall may be appointed to membership on the board who is a member of any political party executive committee or holds any other public office or public employment under the federal government or under the government of this state. Members shall be are eligible for reappointment, and any vacancy on the board shall be filled within thirty days of the vacancy by the governor by appointment for the unexpired term.
A member of the board may not be removed from office except for official misconduct, incompetence, neglect of duty, gross immorality or malfeasance, and then only in the manner prescribed in article six, chapter six of this code for the removal by the governor of the state elected officers.
The board shall hold at least two meetings yearly at such times and places as it may prescribe and may meet at such other times as may be necessary, such the other meetings to be agreed to in writing by at least two of the members. The compensation for members of the board shall each be paid is seventy-five dollars for each calendar day devoted to the work of the board, but not more than seven hundred and fifty dollars during any one fiscal year. Each member shall be reimbursed for all reasonable and necessary expenses actually incurred in the performance of board duties, but shall submit a request therefor for reimbursement upon a sworn itemized statement.
The board is hereby authorized and required to shall administer the grievance procedure at level four levels two, three and four, as provided in section five, article six-a, chapter twenty-nine of this code, and as provided for in section four of this article and shall employ at least two full-time hearing examiners on an annual basis and such clerical help as is necessary to implement the legislative intent expressed in section one of this article.
 In addition to the authorization granted by this section over education employees, the board has jurisdiction over the procedures to be followed in processing grievances filed under article six-a, chapter twenty-nine of this code.
 The board shall hire hearing examiners who reside in different regional educational service agency areas unless and until the number of hearing examiners exceeds the number of such the areas, at which time two hearing examiners may be from the same such area. If a grievant previously before a hearing examiner again brings a grievance, a different hearing examiner shall be is required to hear the grievance upon written request therefor by any party to the grievance. These hearing examiners shall serve at the will and pleasure of the board.
The board shall submit a yearly budget and shall report annually to the governor and Legislature regarding receipts and expenditures, number of level four hearings conducted, synopses of hearing outcomes and such other information as the board may deem determines appropriate. The board shall further evaluate on an annual basis the level four grievance process and the performance of all hearing examiners and include such the evaluation in the annual report to the governor and Legislature. In making such the evaluation, the board shall notify all institutions, employee organizations and all grievants participating in level four grievances in the year for which evaluation is being made and shall provide for the submission of written comment and/or or the hearing of testimony regarding the grievance process, or both. The board shall provide suitable office space for all hearing examiners in space other than that utilized by any institution as defined in section two of this article and shall ensure that reference materials are generally available.
The board is authorized to promulgate rules and regulations consistent with the provisions of this article; such the rules and regulations to shall be adopted in accordance with chapter twenty-nine-a of this code.
(b) Hearing examiners are hereby authorized and shall have the power to may consolidate grievances, allocate costs among the parties in accordance with section eight of this article, subpoena witnesses and documents in accordance with the provisions of section one, article five, chapter twenty-nine-a of this code, provide such relief as is deemed found fair and equitable in accordance with the provisions of this article, and such exercise other powers as will provide provides for the effective resolution of grievances not inconsistent with any rules or regulations of the board or the provisions of this article.
CHAPTER 29. MISCELLANEOUS BOARDS AND OFFICERS.
ARTICLE 6A. GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE FOR STATE EMPLOYEES.
§29-6A-3. Grievance procedure generally.

(a) (1) A grievance must shall be filed within the times specified in section four of this article and shall be processed as rapidly as possible. The number of days indicated at each level specified in section four of this article shall be considered as is the maximum number of days allowed and, if a decision is not rendered at any level within the prescribed time limits, the grievant may appeal to the next level: Provided, That the specified time limits shall be extended whenever a grievant is not working because of accident, sickness, death in the immediate family or other cause necessitating the grievant to take personal leave from his or her employment.
 (2) Any assertion by the employer that the filing of the grievance at level one was untimely shall be asserted by the employer on behalf of the employer at or before the level two hearing. The grievant prevails by default if a grievance evaluator required to respond to a grievance at any level fails to make a required response in the time limits required in this article, unless prevented from doing so directly as a result of sickness, injury, excusable neglect, unavoidable cause or fraud. Within five days of the receipt of a written notice of the default, the employer may request a hearing before a level four hearing examiner for the purpose of showing that the remedy received by the prevailing grievant is contrary to law or clearly wrong. In making a determination regarding the remedy, the hearing examiner shall presume the employee prevailed on the merits of the grievance and shall determine whether the remedy is contrary to law or clearly wrong in light of that presumption. If the examiner finds that the remedy is contrary to law, or clearly wrong, the examiner may modify the remedy to be granted to comply with the law and to make the grievant whole.
(b) If the employer or its agent intends to assert the application of any statute, policy, rule regulation or written agreement or submits any written response to the filed grievance at any level, a copy thereof of the materials shall be forwarded to the grievant and any representative of the grievant named in the filed grievance. Anything submitted and the grievant's response thereto to the submitted materials, if any, shall become becomes part of the record. Failure to assert such the statute, policy, rule regulation or written agreement at any level shall does not prevent the subsequent submission thereof of the materials in accordance with the provisions of this subsection.
(c) The grievant may file the grievance at the level vested with authority to grant the requested relief if each lower administrative level agrees in writing thereto to filing the grievance at a higher level. In the event a grievance is filed at a higher level, the employer shall provide copies to each lower administrative level.
(d) An employee may withdraw a grievance at any time by notice, in writing, to the level wherein where the grievance is then current. The grievance may not be reinstated by the grievant unless reinstatement is granted by the grievance evaluator at the level where the grievance was withdrawn. If more than one employee is named as grievant in a particular grievance, the withdrawal of one employee shall does not prejudice the rights of any other employee named in the grievance. In the event a grievance is withdrawn or an employee withdraws from a grievance, such the employer shall notify, in writing, each lower administrative level.
(e) Grievances may be consolidated at any level by agreement of all parties.
(f) A grievant may be represented by an employee organization representative, legal counsel or any other person, including a fellow employee, in the preparation or presentation of the grievance. At the request of the grievant, such that person or persons may be present at any step of the procedure: Provided, That at level one of such the grievance, as set forth in section four of this article, a grievant may have only one such representative.
(g) If a grievance is filed which cannot be resolved within the time limits set forth in section four of this article prior to the end of the employment term, the time limit set forth in said section shall be reduced as agreed to in writing by both parties so that the grievance procedure may be concluded within ten days following the end of the employment term or an otherwise reasonable time.
(h) No reprisals of any kind shall may be taken by any employer or agent of the employer against any interested party, or any other participant in the grievance procedure by reason of such the participation. A reprisal constitutes a grievance, and any person held to be responsible for reprisal action shall be is subject to disciplinary action for insubordination.
(i) Decisions rendered at all levels of the grievance procedure shall be dated, shall be in writing setting forth the decision or decisions and the reasons therefor for the decision, and shall be transmitted to the grievant and any representative named in the grievance within the time prescribed. If the grievant is denied the relief sought, the decision shall include the name of the individual at the next level to whom appeal may be made.
(j) Once a grievance has been filed, supportive or corroborative evidence may be presented at any conference or hearing conducted pursuant to the provisions of this article. Whether evidence substantially alters the original grievance and renders it a different grievance is within the discretion of the grievance evaluator at the level wherein where the new evidence is presented. If the grievance evaluator rules that the evidence renders it a different grievance, the party offering the evidence may withdraw same it, the parties may consent to such the evidence, or the grievance evaluator may decide to hear the evidence or rule that the grievant must file a new grievance. The time limitation for filing the new grievance shall be is measured from the date of such the ruling.
(k) Any change in the relief sought by the grievant shall be consented to by all parties or may be granted at level four within the discretion of the hearing examiner.
(l) Forms for filing grievances, giving notice, taking appeals, making reports and recommendations, and all other necessary documents shall be made available by the immediate supervisor to any employee upon request. Such The forms shall include information as prescribed by the board. The grievant shall have access to the employer's equipment for purposes of preparing grievance documents subject to the reasonable rules of the employer governing the use of such the equipment.
(m) Notwithstanding the provisions of section three, article nine-a, chapter six of this code, or any other provision relating to open proceedings, all conferences and hearings pursuant to this article shall be conducted in private except that, upon the grievant's request, conferences and hearings at levels two and three shall be open to employees of the grievant's immediate office or work area or, at the request of the grievant, shall be public. Within the discretion of the hearing examiner, conferences and hearings may be public at level four.
(n) No person shall may confer or correspond with a hearing examiner regarding the merits of the grievance unless all parties to the grievance are present.
(o) Grievances shall be processed during regular working hours. Attempts shall be made to process the grievance in a manner which does not interfere with the normal operation of the employer.
(p) The grievant or the employee selected by a grievant to represent him or her in the processing of a grievance through this procedure, or both, shall be granted necessary time off during working hours for the grievance procedure without loss of pay and without charge to annual or compensatory leave credits. In addition to actual time spent in grievance conferences and hearings, the grievant or the employee representative, or both, shall be granted time off during working hours, not to exceed four hours per grievance, for the preparation of such the grievance without loss of pay and without charge to annual or compensatory leave credits. However, it shall be understood by all parties that the first responsibility of any state employee is the work assigned by the appointing authority to the employee. An employee may not allow grievance preparation and representation activities by an employee shall not to seriously affect the overall productivity of the employee.
(q) The aggrieved employee, employing agency and representatives of both shall have the right to call, examine and cross-examine witnesses who are employees of the agency against which the grievance is lodged and who have knowledge of the facts at issue.
(r) Both parties may produce witnesses other than employees of the agency against which the grievance is lodged, and such the witnesses shall be are subject to examination and cross-examination.
(s) Should any If an employer or the employer's agent cause causes a conference or hearing to be postponed without adequate notice to employees who are scheduled to appear during their normal work day, such the employees will may not suffer any loss in pay for work time lost.
(t) Any grievance evaluator may be excused from participation in the grievance process for reasonable cause, including, but not limited to, conflict of interest or incapacitation, and in such case if this occurs the grievance evaluator at the next higher level shall designate an alternative grievance evaluator if such is deemed it is reasonable and necessary.
(u) No less than one year following resolution of a grievance at any level, the grievant may by request in writing have removed any record of the grievant's identity from any file kept by the employer.
(v) All grievance forms and reports shall be kept in a file separate from the personnel file of the employee and shall may not become a part of such the personnel file, but shall remain confidential except by mutual written agreement of the parties.
(w) The number of grievances filed against an employer or agent or by an employee shall is not, per se, be an indication of such the employer's or agent's or such the employee's job performance.
(x) Any chief administrator with whom a grievance was is filed may appeal a level four decision on the grounds that the decision:
(1) was Is contrary to law or a lawfully adopted rule regulation or written policy of the employer;
(2) Exceeded Exceeds the hearing examiner's statutory authority;
(3) was Is the result of fraud or deceit;
(4) was Is clearly wrong in view of the reliable, probative and substantial evidence on the whole record; or
(5) was Is arbitrary or capricious or characterized by abuse of discretion.
Such The appeal shall follow the procedure regarding appeal provided the grievant in section four of this article and provided both parties in section seven of this article.
§29-6A-4. Procedural levels and procedure at each level.

(a) Level one.
Within ten days following the occurrence of the event upon which the grievance is based, or within ten days of the date on which the event became known to the grievant, or within ten days of the most recent occurrence of a continuing practice giving rise to a grievance, the grievant or the designated representative, or both, may file a written grievance with the immediate supervisor of the grievant. At the request of the grievant or the immediate supervisor, an informal conference shall be held to discuss the grievance within three days of the receipt of the written grievance. The immediate supervisor shall issue a written decision within six days of the receipt of the written grievance. If a grievance alleges discrimination or retaliation by the immediate supervisor of the grievant, the level one filing may be waived by the grievant and the grievance may be initiated at level two with the administrator or his or her designee, within the time limits set forth in this subsection for filing a grievance at level one. A meeting may be held to discuss the issues in dispute, but the meeting is not required.
(b) Level two.
Within five days of receiving the decision of the immediate supervisor, the grievant may file a written appeal to the administrator of the grievant's work location, facility, area office, or other appropriate subdivision of the department, board, commission or agency. The administrator or his or her designee shall hold a conference within five days of the receipt of the appeal and issue a written decision upon the appeal within five days of the conference.
(c) Level three.
Within five days of receiving the decision of the administrator of the grievant's work location, facility, area office, or other appropriate subdivision of the department, board, commission or agency, the grievant may file a written appeal of the decision with the chief administrator of the grievant's employing department, board, commission or agency. A copy of the appeal and the level two decision shall be served upon the personnel director of the state civil service commission division of personnel by the grievant.
The chief administrator or his or her designee shall hold a hearing in accordance with section six of this article within seven days of receiving the appeal. The personnel director of the state civil service commission division of personnel or his or her designee may appear at such the hearing and submit oral or written evidence upon the matters in the hearing.
The chief administrator or his or her designee shall issue a written decision affirming, modifying or reversing the level two decision within five days of such the hearing.
(d) Level four.
(1) If the grievant is not satisfied with the action taken by the chief administrator or his or her designee, within five days of the written decision the grievant may request, in writing, on a form furnished by the employer, that the grievance be submitted to a hearing examiner as provided for in section five of this article. such The hearing to shall be conducted in accordance with section six of this article within fifteen days following the request therefor for the hearing: Provided, That such the hearing may be held within thirty days following the request, or within such a time as that is mutually agreed upon by the parties, if the hearing examiner gives reasonable cause, in writing, as to the necessity for such the delay. A copy of the appeal shall be served by the grievant upon the director of the division of personnel. of the state civil service commission The director of the division of personnel, of the state civil service commission or his or her designee, may appear at such the hearing and submit oral or written evidence upon the matters in the hearing.
(2) Within thirty days following the hearing, the hearing examiner shall render a decision in writing to all parties setting forth findings and conclusions on the issues submitted. Subject to the provisions of section seven of this article, the decision of the hearing examiner shall be is final upon the parties and shall be is enforceable in circuit court.
(e) Expedited grievance process.
(1) A grievance involving suspension without pay, demotion or dismissal or loss of wages may be initiated at level two with the administrator of the grievant's work location, facility, area office, or other appropriate subdivision of the department, board, commission or agency.
 (2) An employee may grieve a final action of the employer involving a dismissal, demotion or suspension exceeding twenty days directly to the hearing examiner. The expedited grievance shall be in writing and must shall be filed within ten days of the date of the final action with the chief administrator and the director of the division of personnel. of the state civil service commission
§29-6A-5. Education and state employees grievance board; hearing examiners.

(a) The education employees grievance board, created by virtue of the provisions of section five, article twenty-nine, chapter eighteen of this code, shall be hereafter known and referred to as is renamed the education and state employees grievance board and, in addition to those duties set forth in said chapter eighteen, is hereby authorized and required to shall administer the grievance procedure at level four as provided for in section four of this article. The board has jurisdiction regarding procedural matters at levels two and three of the grievance procedure. The board shall employ, in addition to those persons employed as hearing examiners for educational employee grievances, at least two full-time hearing examiners for the purpose of conducting hearings at level four, as provided in section four of this article. Such The hearing examiners shall be are employed on an annual basis along with such the clerical help as is necessary to implement the legislative intent expressed in section one of this article.
In addition to the budget required for submission to the Legislature by virtue of the provisions of section five, article twenty-nine, chapter eighteen of this code, the board shall submit a yearly budget and shall report annually to the governor and the Legislature regarding proceedings conducted under this article, including receipts and expenditures, the number of level four hearings conducted, synopses of hearing outcomes and such other information as the board may deem determines appropriate. The board shall further evaluate on an annual basis the level four grievance process and the performance of all hearing examiners and include such the evaluation in the annual report to the governor and the Legislature. In making such the evaluation the board shall notify all employers, employee organizations, the director of the division of personnel of the state civil service commission and all grievants participating in level four grievances in the year for which evaluation is being made and shall provide for the submission of written comment and/or or the hearing of testimony regarding the grievance process, or both.
The board shall provide suitable office space for all hearing examiners in space other than that utilized by any employer as defined in section two of this article and shall ensure that reference materials are generally available. The board shall provide forms for filing grievances, giving notice, taking appeals, making reports and recommendations and such other documents as the board deems determines necessary for any stage of a grievance under this article.
The board is authorized to promulgate propose rules for promulgation and regulations consistent with the provisions of this article, such rules and regulations to be adopted and in accordance with article three, chapter twenty-nine-a of this code.
(b) Hearing examiners are hereby authorized and shall have the power to may consolidate grievances, allocate costs among the parties in accordance with section eight of this article, subpoena witnesses and documents in accordance with the provisions of section one, article five, chapter twenty-nine-a of this code, provide such relief as is deemed determined fair and equitable in accordance with the provisions of this article, and such other powers as will take any other action to provide for the effective resolution of grievances not inconsistent with any rules and regulations of the board or the provisions of this article: Provided, That in all cases the hearing examiner shall have has the authority to provide appropriate remedies including, but not limited to, making the employee whole.
§29-6A-6. Hearings generally.

(a) The chief administrator or his or her designee acting as a grievance evaluator or the hearing examiner shall conduct all hearings in an impartial manner and shall ensure that all parties are accorded procedural and substantive due process. All parties shall have an opportunity to present evidence and argument with respect to the matters and issues involved, to cross-examine and to rebut evidence. Reasonable notice of a hearing shall be sent prior to the hearing to all parties and their named representative and shall include the date, time and place of the hearing. Level one, level two and level three hearings shall be at a convenient place accessible to the aggrieved employee. All such hearings shall be held on the employer's premises or on other premises mutually agreeable to the parties and within regular working hours: Provided, That any such hearing might continue beyond normal working hours. Level four hearings shall be at a place to be designated by the hearing examiner.
(b) The employer that is party to the grievance shall produce prior to such the hearing any documents, not privileged, and which are relevant to the subject matter involved in the pending grievance, that have been requested by the grievant, in writing.
(c) The chief administrator or his or her designee or the hearing examiner shall have has the power to (1) administer oaths and affirmations; (2) subpoena witnesses; (3) regulate the course of the hearing; (4) hold conferences for the settlement or simplification of the issues; by consent of the parties (5) exclude immaterial, irrelevant or repetitious evidence; (6) sequester witnesses; (7) restrict the number of advocates; and (8) take any other action not inconsistent with the rules and regulations of the board or the provisions of this article.
(d) All the testimony and evidence at any level three or level four hearing shall be recorded by mechanical means, and all recorded testimony and evidence at such the hearing shall be transcribed and certified by affidavit. The chief administrator shall be is responsible for promptly providing a copy of the certified transcript of a level three hearing to any party to that hearing who requests such the transcript. The hearing examiner may also request and be provided a transcript upon appeal to level four and allocate the costs therefor for the transcript as prescribed in section eight of this article. The board shall be is responsible for promptly providing a copy of the certified transcript of a level four hearing to any party to that hearing who requests such the transcript.
(e) Formal rules of evidence shall may not be applied, but parties shall be are bound by the rules of privilege recognized by law. No employee shall may be compelled to testify against himself or herself in a grievance involving disciplinary action. The burden of proof shall rest rests with the employer in disciplinary matters.
(f) All materials submitted in accordance with section three of this article; the mechanical recording of all testimony and evidence or the transcription thereof of the testimony, if any; the decision; and any other materials considered in reaching the decision shall be made a part and shall constitute are the record of a grievance. Such The record shall be submitted to any level at which appeal has been made, and such the record shall be considered, but the development of such the record shall is not be limited thereby.
(g) Every decision pursuant to a hearing shall be in writing and shall be accompanied by findings of fact and conclusions of law.
(h) Prior to such the decision any party may propose findings of fact and conclusions of law.
§29-6A-7. Enforcement and reviewability; costs; good faith.

(a) The decision of the hearing examiner shall be is final upon the parties and shall be is enforceable in circuit court. Provided, That
(b) Either party or the state civil service commission director of the division of personnel may appeal to the circuit court of Kanawha County or to the circuit court of the county in which the grievance occurred on the grounds that the hearing examiner's decision:
(1) was Is contrary to law or a lawfully adopted rule regulation or written policy of the employer;
(2) exceeded Exceeds the hearing examiner's statutory authority;
(3) was Is the result of fraud or deceit;
(4) was Is clearly wrong in view of the reliable, probative and substantial evidence on the whole record; or
(5) was Is arbitrary or capricious or characterized by abuse of discretion or clearly unwarranted exercise of discretion.
(c) Such The appeal shall be filed in the circuit court of the county in which the grievance occurred within thirty days of receipt of the hearing examiner's decision. The decision of the hearing examiner shall not be stayed, is not automatically stayed upon the filing of an appeal, but a stay may be granted by the circuit court upon separate motion therefor for a stay.
(d) The court's ruling shall be upon the entire record made before the hearing examiner, and the court may hear oral arguments and require written briefs. The court may reverse, vacate or modify the decision of the hearing examiner or may remand the grievance to the appropriate chief administrator for further proceedings.
(e) Both employer and employee shall at all times act in good faith and make every possible effort to resolve disputes at the lowest level of the grievance procedure. The hearing examiner may make a determination of bad faith and in extreme instances allocate the cost of the hearing to the party found to be acting in bad faith. Such The allocation of costs shall be based on the relative ability of the party to pay such the costs.
§29-6A-10. Employee's right to attorney's fees and costs.

If an employee shall appeal appeals to a circuit court an adverse decision of a hearing examiner rendered in a grievance proceeding pursuant to provisions of this article or is required to defend an appeal and such the person shall substantially prevail prevails, the adverse party or parties shall be is liable to such the employee, upon final judgment or order, for court costs, and for reasonable attorney's fees, to be set by the court, for representing such the employee in all administrative hearings and before the circuit court and the supreme court of appeals, and shall be is further liable to such the employee for any court reporter's costs incurred during any such administrative hearings or court proceedings: Provided, That in no event shall such attorney's fees be awarded in excess of a total of one thousand five hundred dollars for the administrative hearings and circuit court proceedings nor an additional one thousand dollars for supreme court proceedings: Provided, however, That the requirements of this section shall not be construed to limit the employee's right to recover reasonable attorney's fees in a mandamus proceeding brought under section nine of this article.
 §29-6A-12. Mediation required at request of either party.
Upon the request of either party, the board may require mediation or other alternative dispute resolution technique to assist the parties in identifying, clarifying and resolving issues regarding the grievance. Mediation may be requested at any time prior to the level four hearing. All of the information that is provided by parties during mediation is and shall remain confidential. Mediators may not be called as witnesses to provide testimony in unresolved grievances that proceed to a grievance hearing, and any hearing examiner involved in a mediation process may not hear the grievance or be consulted regarding the merits of the grievance.